Saturday, May 8, 2010

Scales: Factors of 3.33?

The last few nights while falling asleep I've been consumed with thoughts of scales. I'm not exactly sure why. Part of it is probably intrigue with Delta's mass battle engine, and part of it is planning my own real world hexploration adventures.

Previously I've talked about using scales of 10 or something else. I kind of settled on these scales which are roughly factors of 7-10. However, I was thinking that scales of 3.333 might work even better. They have a few good points about them:
  • The factor of 10 -- pointed out by readers as a handy, easy to use value -- is preserved. Look at this sequence: 1, 3.3, 10, 33, 100, 333, 1000, etc... Every other number increases by 10. So mental math is easy: all you ever have to multiply by is 3 or 10.
  • A reasonable number of different powered elements can all be portrayed on one board. Say we want to do a mass battle with low level heroes. We can portray level 3 PCs as one figure. "Fireteams" of 3-5 zero levels can be portrayed as one figure. A giant of ~9 HD can be portrayed as a "superfigure;" it can appear in the same battle even though it is one scale higher, and is a reasonable challenge. A sea monster of 30 HD could also appear as an ultrafigure; if played largely as a solo figure it might be an extremely challenging threat that is barely within the realm of being handled, with luck and a lot of resources. Contrast this to the scales of 10: the next jump in scale up for a level 3 party would be 30 HD foes, which is not nearly as smooth a progression as a 9 HD giant.
  • This has major implications for surviveability (the "no heroes in war" phenomenon). If a 1 HD PC is facing off against a unit comprised of 10 men-at-arms, no duh, he's very likely to die. However, if a 1 HD PC is facing off against a unit comprised of 3 or 4, he is much more likely to survive. This allows you to reap one of the largest advantages of a sane scaling system: condensing encounters down. For example, say you want to play out searching for a campsite. You go to the scale of 1-turn (movement in furlongs) to map out a manor-sized area. The entire party is likely represented by 1-2 tokens at this scale unless they are high level. If the PCs come across an encounter, you have a few options: play it out at the segment-by-segment level (mandatory if it is a significant threat), arbitrarily reduce the party's resources (boring), or play it out at the higher level of scale. With a 1:10 figure system, that is not very exciting because anything that is a challenge (multiple tokens) is likely to kill all the PCs. But with the 1:3 system it is more feasible. You could have three tokens representing 18 HD worth of PCs/retainers/pack animals and two tokens representing 12 HD of orcs and one uber-token representing 12 HD of giant and play out an interesting battle withou the PCs automatically dying. The entire battle could be played out on the furlong/turn scale without needing to "zoom in" on the action.
The scales would look something like this in the world of 3.333. The new levels are added in bold:
  • 1 year (12 months)
  • 1 season (3 months)
  • 1 month: 48 leagues (consider rounding to 40, 45, or 50) -- ~850 x 1300 miles (empire or small continent)
  • 10 days: 18 leagues
  • 1 week: 12 leagues -- ~215 x 325 miles (kingdom)
  • 3 days: 6 leagues
  • 1 day: 2 leagues -- 36 x 54 miles (duchy?)
  • Morning/Afternoon/Night (1/3 of a day): 1 league, with one part usually reserved for downtime
  • 2 hour "chunks:" 2 miles (if you require 2 chunks/day for downtime)...or 0.5 leagues (if downtime is abstracted -- 12 x 18 miles or 9 x 13.5 miles (barony?)
  • 1 mini-chunk (~40 mins): 1/2 mile
  • 1 turn (~10 mins): 1 furlong (220 yards) -- 6/8 mile x 9/8 mile (manor)
  • 1 partial-turn (~3 minutes): 3.3 chains (~70 yards)
  • 1 minute (~60 seconds): 1 chain/4 rods (22 yards) -- ~130 x 200 yards (5 acres)
  • 1 round (~20 seconds): 1 rod (5.5 yards)
  • 1 segment (~6 seconds): 1 pace (~1.5 yards) -- 10 x 15 yards (perch, or 1/160th of an acre)
Everything works fairly smoothly except for weeks (which end up being 10 days long, not 7 days long) and years (which should be 10 months, not 12 months in length). Those can either be changed -- the fantasy world fits the mathematical necessities -- or adjusted slightly to make the slightly different scales work. The downside to this is that you get many more scales in the game. Instead of seven scales bringing you from segments to the strategic levels of play, you now have twice as many. However, there are significant gains in playability.

I think you could mitigate the excessive number of levels by clearly splitting the game into tiers; if you split the game into three broad tiers (tactical/operational/strategic for lack of better terms) then there would only be 5 or so scales in each tier, which is pretty much perfect for readily utilizing. For example, at the tactical level (think low level dungeon crawling), the entire party would be represented as ~3 tokens on a minute-by-minute scale much of the time while exploring a dungeon one chain at a time. For very difficult or important battles, you can zoom in to round-by-round (~9 friendly tokens on the map, representing each PC + their retainers/bodyguards, plus maybe a few extra tokens for important henchmen or the pack train) or even segment-by-segment action (~27 friendly tokens on the map -- representing every bodyguard, pack animal, and PC in explicit detail). For covering larger areas, you can zoom out to partial turns (where the party is represented as 1-2, honest, full strength tokens) or even turns (where the party is dramatically "undergunned" and represented as <1 full token).


Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...


DHBoggs said...

You might find it interesting that in Adventures in Fantasy, Arneson and Snider had 1 minute rounds divided into 3 twenty second segments.

怡潔 said...


Anonymous said...

朋友是一面鏡子 ............................................................

琬真 said...

視訊聊天網A片-殺很大成人a影片論壇kk777視訊俱樂部avdvd情色影片嘟嘟無碼a片情色視訊聊天視訊交友聊天室avdvd無碼情色電影卡通美女a片免費試看小魔女免費影片3d美女視訊免費看哈拉網路成人區jp成人jp58avooo影音a 片天堂ut影音視訊聊天室13077aa免費影片s383情色大網咖免費 a片網愛聊天室hilive-免費影片甜心寶貝貼影片免費成人片觀賞xvediox免費影片sod特輯sex520免費影片yawuuthome 視訊聊天室av女優王國情色a片flashxyzutobe 影片分享小弟貼影片bt成人免費視訊美眉A片-sex520免費 a 片獸皇影片分享區小澤圓線上免費影片女生自衛影片日本a電影okav成人影院免費avdvd影片免費線上影片 情色a片免費無碼a片小魔女影片交流嘟嘟情人色網影片華人色片ol 線上免費影片葉子媚影片分享色瞇瞇影片網熟女人影片金瓶影片交流區-無碼a片免費影片-無碼a片免費影片欣賞aaaaa7777788卡提諾成人免費線上影片觀看avdvd免費無碼a片台灣kiss情色貼圖色妹妺免費影片觀賞