Monday, February 23, 2009

Units of Distance & Time

Here's a comparison of customary units of distance with approximate times that might be appropriate for a game.

1 FOOT vs. 1 SECOND

PACE (5', ~FATHOM) vs. "ROUND" (5-6 SECONDS)

FURLONG/STADIA (1/8 mile, 625 feet) vs. "TURN" (~7.5 minutes -- we can round to 10 to make it simple)

LEAGUE (3 miles) vs . HOUR

MARATHON (26 miles, ~8 leagues) vs. DAY

Note these are customary units. You'd use the scale most appropriate for the scene. So, tactical combat is probably measured in PACES and goes in 5-6 second periods of time. "Strategic" movement is going to be covered over days and measured in Marathons. Note that the Marathon isn't really a customary unit of measure, but it is about as far as you go in a full day's march (8 leagues).

Furlongs and Leagues fill in the middle. A furlong and 8-10 minute chunks of time would be most appropriate for, say, exploring a dungeon. A league is better for overland travel or exploring, say, an enchanted wood.

THE RULE OF THREE STRIKES AGAIN

Note that certain circumstances could bend these scales.
- An athlete can cover about 3-6 paces every 5 seconds over short distances (the higher end of that being an olympian in a sprint).
- A race horse can cover a furlong in about 10-15 seconds (3 rounds).
- A good time for a 5K (about 3 miles) is around 20 minutes (hrm... 2-3 "turns").
- And a runner in a marathon finishes in... hrm... around 3 hours!

So, with significant effort, one can cover distances at an order of magnitude faster, combined with a x3 modifier.

Obviously circumstances might slow you down, too. One is reminded of the 1E rule for distances covered, where 1" was 10 feet inside but 10 yards outside (the rule of three strikes again!). So perhaps in a particularly difficult dungeon, one might only cover 1 furlong every 3 turns instead of 1 furlong every 1 turn. Likewise, if picking through a bog or swamp, one might cover a league every 3 hours instead of a league every hour.

This has some other implications for bending scales. Say we let a fighter dash a furlong in 3 rounds with some sort of successful check. Why couldn't a magic-user then cast a ritual which normally takes a whole turn in 3 rounds with a successful check then as well?

ADDENDUM:

Here's a magic system thought. First, we've got our various scales:
FOOT/SECOND/Hit Point
PACE/ROUND/Hit Dice
FURLONG/TURN/Individual
LEAGUE/HOUR/Party
MARATHON/DAY/Company

Most tactical combat occurs at the PACE/ROUND scale. Perhaps most useful magical effects should reside at the FURLONG/TURN scale or higher. Basically many spells want to knock an individual out of the fight anyways (either by status effect or straight damage), or they seek to effect the target a furlong away (magic missile anyone?), or they effect larger than a few paces (fireball). Thus they are tasks that rightly belong at the "turn" cast time level.

To cast something useful in combat requires the accelerated check as described above, with perhaps 2-3 successes required. Mitigating this could be a small repertoire of "Signature Spells" or "Power Words" that the character knows that may be cast rapidly, as rapidly as one swings a sword or shoots an arrow; but using a signature spell might cost some sort of consumable resource.

Skill Lists

Here are some lists of skills that I've found that nicely fall into groups of sevens:

THE LIBERAL ARTS
Logic
Grammar
Rhetoric
Arithmetic
Geometry (Geography)
Music
Astronomy (Calendar)

THE MECHANICAL ARTS
Vestiaria (tailoring, weaving)
Agricultura (agriculture)
Architectura (architecture, masonry)
Militia and venatoria (warfare and hunting, "martial arts")
Mercatura (trade, commerce)
Coquinaria (cooking)
Metallaria (blacksmithing, metallurgy)
The above list is per Johannes Scotus Eriugena.

Another list replaces Commerce with Navigation, Agriculture with Medicine, and Cooking with Theatrical Arts (Hugh of St Victor). Yet another list replaces Architectura with "Armaments," which broadly includes working with stones, woods, metals, sands, and clays. "The later medieval tradition arrayed the mechanical arts in a range from technological to economic subjects: shoemaking, armaments, commerce, tailoring, metalwork, and alchemy, and occasionally agriculture, navigation, and music, among others."

A bit more:
Hugh's classification strikes a modern eye in that the mechanical arts appear at the top level. Suddenly, after having no place in philosophy whatsoever, they become one of four primary divisions. As I mentioned, John the Scot claims that there are seven mechanical arts, to balance the seven liberal arts, and Hugh chooses them to parallel the trivium and quadrivium:. personifying nature, he says, “three pertain to external cover for nature, by which she protects herself from harm” (fabric-making, armament, and commerce) and “four to internal, by which she feeds and nourishes herself” (agriculture, hunting, medicine, and theatrics).[18] Hugh explains that the trivium is external and the quadrivium is internal in nature, and he thereby partially justifies his inclusion of the mechanical arts in what had previously been closed to them. In order to fulfill his claim that “These four [divisions] contain all knowledge,”[19] his classifications encompass more than is immediately suggested by their titles. For example, through some circuitous reasoning, Hugh classifies “all such materials as stones, woods, metals, sands, and clays” under “armament.”[20] He thereby includes here all technologies such as carpentry, masonry, cooperage, joinery, and metal casting.
http://www.compilerpress.atfreeweb.com/Anno%20Walton%20An%20Introduction%20to%20the%20Mechanical%20Arts%20in%20the%20Middle%20Ages%20AVISTA%202003.htm

We may find a similar list of seven mechanical arts
according to the utility of their ends in the writings of Radulphus de Campo Longo, called
the Fiery (Ardens). Radulphus mentions the following: ars victuaria—the art of feeding
people; ars lanificaria—the art of dressing people; ars architectura—the art of providing
shelter; ars suffragatoria—the art of means of transport; ars medicinaria—the art of healing;
ars negotiatoria—the skill of trading goods; ars militaria—the art of defence against an
enemy.
http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:zmAHQIExhGYJ:ptta.pl/pef/haslaen/a/artes.pdf+Artes+Mechanicae&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=24&gl=us&client=firefox-a

THE MARTIAL ARTS (KNIGHT'S ARTS)
Riding
Tilting
Fencing
Wrestling
Running
Leaping
Spear-Throwing

THE FACULTY
Philosophy/Theology
History
Law
Medicine
Nature
Alchemy (often considered a mechanical art)
Arcana (added for "game balance"

Artes Magicae (the forbidden arts)
Nigromancy (demonology, necromancy, "high magic" as from a grimoire)
Geomancy (earth)
Hydromancy (water)
Aeromancy (air)
Pyromancy (fire)
Chiromancy (Divination from palms)
Scapulimancy (Divination from animal bones)

Whether they could form the foundation for a skill system is debatable, but it does have some pseudo-historical flavor!

AC and HP Scaling

All versions of D&D to date have used two main defenses in combat: Armor Class (or some standin such as Reflex or Will) and Hit Points. Typically an attacker first determines if he hits (rolls vs. AC) and then determines how hard he hits (rolls damage). In most versions of D&D, AC and HP both increase with monster level. This forces PCs to constantly keep up or risk being useless in combat. It also creates some problems -- the designer needs to find a way to scale PC damage up with level. That 1d8 long sword just doesn't pack the same punch against a 60 HP Fire Giant as it did against a 6 HP Orc. Various methods that attempted to resolve this problem include magic weapons, AD&D's multiple attacks for fighter types, spells that do more damage with level, and increasing amounts of Sneak Attack damage (multiplier in AD&D, SA in 3E/4E).

Increasing monster HP has a few ramifications:
- It makes monsters less vulnerable to the "golden BB" -- As we all know, D20s are highly variable. A first level character might roll a 20 and hit a powerful monster. By giving Smaug many HP, then that hit will not take out the powerful dragon. This basically reduces the variability of the game in one direction.
- If AC is the same as other monsters, it increases the "screen time" and staying power of a monster, like a Solo or Elite monster.
- If AC is lower than other monsters, it creates a different feeling monster (4E's Brute -- easy to hit but absorbs a lot of punishment)
- If AC is higher than other monsters, it basically creates a higher level monster.

Note that the only one of these that relates to the player's level is the Golden BB issue. If we can find a way to solve the Golden BB issue, then we can keep monster HP "fixed" regardless of level and just vary it in regards to AC. Then AC becomes our only factor that changes with level. We then deftly side step the whole escalating damage issue altogether. This vastly simplifies our entire combat system. Also, it allows monsters to be used over a wider variety of "levels" -- as anyone that's fought a higher-level monster in 4E knows, lower level characters just can't tear through the massive HP fast enough. And in 1E, a higher level monster may be able to one-shot a PC just because it does so much damage.

To resolve the Golden BB issue, you can do a few things:
- Set defenses/ACs high enough that lower-than-desired characters just can't hit them.
- Set up some sort of Deus Ex Machina mechanic to ensure that the campaign's arch-villain doesn't get one shotted by a first level hero in the first scene.
- Not worry about it -- a single archer brought down Smaug, and sometimes the heros get lucky.

Honestly, I prefer the middle option (deus ex machina). This is because of the "What is Good for the Goose" rule, in part -- I don't want PCs to be one shotted by giant rats at level 10. Also, I don't want to rely soley on manipulating ACs, because then % chance to hits might get so low or high that the game isn't fun anymore.

Agon/Irontooth dice pool style mechanic

MECHANIC 1: IRONTOOTH/AGON-ish

So I've been thinking about a potential Dice Mechanic that could be used in a Swords & Sorcery clone. It parallels the Agon/dice pool/Irontooth models I've discussed earlier in this blog. Basically, you roll a dice pool and retain only the highest and then compare it to a TN of some sort.

TIER DIE: This is a D4, D6, D8, D10, D12, or D20 based on your "level." The D20 is likely just for NPCs (deities and the like) at very high levels of play.

SKILL DIE: This is a D4 through D12 based on level of skill. Characters will be good at some things and bad at others.

BONUS DIE: Players can spend a consumable resource (let's call it "Fate") to add a bonus die into the mix. Some magic items, racial abilities, etc might also let you throw in a bonus die too from time to time (perhaps a Flame Tongue against an Icy Monster, or a Dwarf smacking a hated goblinoid).

GOOD THINGS ABOUT THIS MECHANIC:
- Simple, quick easy. No math required.
- Provides a "floor." All characters are likely able to attain some sort of minimum result because of the nature of dice pools, especially if they get a bonus die. Even an untrained character (the weakling mage with a D4 for physical combat) has a decent chance to succeed if he's of sufficient tier.
- Hard to stack. You can't really pile on extra dice/modifiers.

BAD THINGS ABOUT THIS MECHANIC:
- Hard to predict odds.
- Tops out at three dice. Once you add the third die, the average is already skewed strongly upward. Adding extra dice has little statistical effect other than ensuring that characters get max or near-max results every time. This is why Agon cleverly splits combat dice pools into an Attack Pool and Defense Pool.
- Low level, unskilled characters have no chance of attaining difficult goals. If you're rolling 2d6 and the TN is 8, you're hosed. This may be a good thing if you don't want low level mages to be able to even hit a very strong foe's armor. If the "fate" system allows one to add a large enough die then some success may still be possible.

An advanced version might address the topping out issue by splitting the pool into two somehow. Accuracy & Impact, Attack & Defense, etc. That would allow you to throw 3-5 dice into a player's pool, giving more room for modifiers, bonuses, etc.

MECHANIC 2: Dream Pod 9-ish dice pools

Another dice pool method could be using a pool of dice and retaining the largest. DP9 uses D6s; so, you might throw 3d6 and just retain the highest. There is a twist; multiple 6s add +1 to the total. So if you roll 4, 6, 6, the result is 7. One's skill would determine the number of dice in your pool.

A possible twist to scale it with 'tier' of play would be to increase the die size to D8, D10, or even D12. Thus, a 2nd tier challenge with a TN of 7 is still attainable by a skilled Tier 1 character who can chuck enough D6s to get multiple 6s, but its significantly easier for a Tier 2 character throwing D8s.

GOOD THINGS ABOUT THIS MECHANIC:
- Still simple and pretty easy.
- Also provides a floor.

BAD THINGS ABOUT THIS MECHANIC:
- Again, tops out around 3 dice. More than that is not really meaningful. This limits the relevance of skill levels and such.
- Difficult to modify, due to the 3 die limit. If you drop someone below 1 die, what happens? If you give bonus dice for whatever reason, it may be either very helpful (going from 1d6 to 2d6 is a lot better than going from 4d6 to 5d6).

ADDENDUM:

If you want more variability in your game, that's easy. Just add another die to the Dice Pool result, and add the average of that die to your TN.

For example, you could add 1d20+DICE POOL, and just tack another +10 on to every TN. That will make rolls highly variable, with chance being more important than skill.

You could also just add on a D8 + DICE POOL and tack +4 or +5 onto the TNs. That will make chance and ability roughly equal.

Saturday, February 21, 2009

Immediate Patches for 4E

1) Change the XP system. Right now 4E rewards combat 80% and quests 20%. In 1E, you got rewarded treasure (quest) 80%, combat 20%. That means that in 4E, combat is the preferred and best solution to almost every problem. If the players are clever and manage to avoid or attrit a combat encounter, the GM often feels guilty handing out full XP. Because in 4E, XP is linked to treasure, players basically get zero reward for avoiding combat. Players will not seek out creative (non-violent) solutions unless they are rewarded for doing so. This turns most adventures into a room-to-room clearing exercise where the players wipe out everything in the dungeon, with many of the "easy" encounters not really posing any threat; they just provide XP and sap resources.

2) A Focused Campaign. 4E is built out of the box to support a very, very wide idea of fantasy gaming. There's multiple planes of existence, skills to handle everything from mountaineering to lying to the Duke to dungeon crawling, and a broad variety of classes. It isn't as bad as other editions, but at this point I would prefer to look at a smaller topic in greater detail (deep and narrow over broad and shallow). Also, with the characters potentially hailing from very different places mechanically, the only thing they have in common is tactical combat. So, what will they do? Tactical Combat, every time. The fix, I think, is working with the players to create a cohesive party and themed game. Maybe we're playing "Knights and Knaves" and players are restricted to the Martial Power Source. Perhaps the players are in a Sorcerer's Guild and are all Arcane Power Source. Maybe all characters must be Fey creatures, or part of a thieve's guild, or something. This may entail granting carrots (characters of X trait gain some sort of benefit, free multiclass feats) or sticks (outright bans of certain material).

3) Morality. D&D has always been designed to mechanically support "low" fantasy, that is, Swords & Sorcery. See my post on "survival" for more on this line of thought. I would either implement a morally gray Swords & Sorcery "sell swords for hire" campaign world, or add some sort of mechanic (morality, honor/shame, virtue/vice, something) to reward and encourage "heroic" or desired behavior.

4) Out of Combat. Non-combat activities need some serious thought. If you want people to do something other than Tactical Combat it has to be interesting. Tweaking of the skill challenge system is the most obvious route.

Agon

http://www.agon-rpg.com/

I just found this RPG. It incorporates a lot of the mechanics I've been thinking about lately. Well worth a look at the free sample, at least! The combat system seems a bit clunky and I dislike the blackjack-degree of success, but in general it looks pretty fun.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Survival isn't everything

In many RPGs, especially D&D, survival is the main behavior that is rewarded. A D&D player will be loathe to nobly sacrifice his character in most cases because the game rewards surviving the adventure, gaining treasure, and adding experience. This causes problems when the campaign envisions noble characters who act... well, heroically. Most GMs are well aware of the players skeptically investigating the quest, asking "Well, how do much exactly do we get paid to rescue that princess?" or "So, do those undead that keep swarming out of the crypts have any good loot?" Additionally, players that are weaker role players have no guidance on how to perform better, so they tend to strongly focus on the mechanical aspects of their character, seeing it as merely a collection of items and stats.

In Campbell's heroic cycle, the ultimate hallmark of a hero is determining who he is (self-awareness/knowledge) and what he will do. Most games though have no in-character way of determining what you are.

Thus, the game needs some sort of system that gives players a payoff of some sort for ignoring their immediate short-term interests (survival). The White Wolf games do this to some degree; players can make expedient choices that likely aid in meeting short term goals or surviving, but they will pay a price in their Morality score.

Here's one such system that is fairly system neutral.

Each character chooses an archetype or value to live up to. The GM should provide a list that will give focus to the game. For example, he might ask players to select from a moral code or list of classic archetypes. For a tightly focused game, the GM might restrict the players to all selecting from one list of traits, and each player selects one or two that is their primary focus (all players select from the Knightly Virtues). For a wider ranging game with more intraparty conflict, each player might select one entire category to represent (so one player follows Pashtunwali, one follows the Knightly code, another follows Bushido).
- THE SEVEN VIRTUES
- THE SEVEN DEADLY SINS (perhaps appropriate for an evil game!)
- PASHTUNWALI (Hospitality, Justice/Revenge, Asylum, Land/Earth, Honor)
- THE KNIGHT'S CODE (Courage, Justice, Mercy, Generosity, Faith, Nobility, Hope)
- BUSHIDO (Rectitude, Courage, Benevolence, Respect, Honesty, Honor/Glory, Loyalty)
- CLASSIC ARCHETYPES (The Wise Old Man/Expert, the Child/Innocent, the Trickster)
- GREYHAWK DEITIES

Each player is rated from 0 to 6, and their rating is generated randomly using 1d6 (thus players will start with a score of 1-6). 0 means "absolute focus on survival" and 6 means "paragon of chosen attribute." Players must not know their rating; it is recorded secretly by the GM. Ratings can increase and decrease during play.

INCREASING A RATING
If a player makes a significant sacrifice for their attribute, they are entitled to an attempt to increase their rating. To do this, they roll 1d6 and announce the result. If its higher than their current rating (known only by the GM), then their rating increases by one. If the result is equal to or less than their rating, their rating remains unchanged.

It is suggested that DMs only allow these rolls in limited circumstances:
- Once every "milestone" (every other encounter or so)
- Once after completing a minor or major quest
- Once after any major, obvious act that sacrifices survival for the code (should be rare)

Alternate Rule: The GM rolls the Increase Die. Thus the player has no clue if their score is even likely to have gone up!

DECREASING A RATING
Sometimes ratings decrease. They gradually decay over time, encouraging players to always continue to adhere to their code. It also decreases when the player calls on their code.

A decrease roll should be made:
- Once every fixed period of time that encompasses 2-3 milestones (could be every day or every other day).
- When a player particularly flagrantly violates their code.

If the roll is lower than the player's current score, it decreases by one.

CASHING IN YOUR CODE
A player may voluntarily accept a decrease roll in exchange for certain benefits. A player can actually attempt to change the game world. The player states what they want to happen; it must be in-line with the code. For example, a Knight that adheres to the principle of Mercy could say, "The chief of the monsters that just captured us will decide to be merciful on us."

The GM then secretly rolls 1d6. If it is equal to or lower than the current rating, then the player's request is granted and the story world alters slightly. If it is greater than the current rating, then the request fails, but that may not be immediately obvious! Regardless, the player's rating decreases by one.

SPECIAL: If the player's rating is zero, and they attempt to cash in their code, the attempt automatically fails (although the GM should still role a die, and ignore the result). Additionally, depending on the setting, the Fates or Gods may be offended that such a heretic is imploring their aid and punish the individual appropriately.

A NOBLE DEATH
"If you strike me down… I shall become more powerful than you can imagine.”

If a character is near death or actually dies in the service of their code, the player may declare it a Noble Death. This has several benefits:

- Their next character begins with some sort of extra benefit, depending on the system.
- If they retain their current character, they may cheat death. This means that they miraculously return from the grave, recover, or are reincarnated. Perhaps the knight was mortally wounded and left for dead on the field by his enemies. Or, a prophet is raised from the dead by his God after three days to continue spreading the word. A mighty wizard returns from shadow and flame. Mechanically, this is a "freebie" mulligan.

This only works if the character's score is 5 or 6. It automatically reduces their score to 0. If the character's score is lower than 5, then the attempt automatically fails AND the character still has their score reduced to 0.